When it comes to the lowly chicken, the price range can be vast. Last week I found chicken prices ranging from $3.99 to $10.98 a kilo. That’s an almost 300% difference. The first price was from a discount grocer and the second from an upscale market. They are both from the same day, for the same cut (whole leg, bone-in, backs attached), both the same expiry date. The only variable? One is organic.
Even if I were to take organic out of the equation, there is still a huge price difference between various poultry choices. I could opt for aforementioned discount legs—conveniently tossed loose in a bag—or the more attractively packaged (but worse for the earth?) Styrofoam tray of legs for $8.65 a kilo. (This direct comparison begins to run into some difficulty here as the cuts are a bit different; more on that below.) Or maybe I should hedge my bets and buy the “free of everything nasty except still not eating organic because he thinks that’s taking things just one step too far” chicken for $6.90 a kilo. (Wait! Did I just say it was cheaper than conventional—cannibal—chicken? Yes, yes I did.)
So, there was only one thing to do…some unregulated testing on my loved ones. I decided to go whole-hog, er, whole chicken…leg…and compare several options. I chose legs over breasts because—with a stronger flavour to begin with—I figured any variance in taste would be more noticeable. After bouncing between three different grocers to obtain a total of four samples in a single day, I butchered them as necessary and tossed them in my fridge for a day to ensure they were the same temperature. Finally I roasted them together, after which they were carefully assessed by my crack team of me, my husband, and our six-year-old. (We’re “experts” now. I’m slapping that on my résumé, baby.)
A note on trimming: Two of the four samples (the cheapest and most expensive, go figure) came with the backs attached. I trimmed away the backs and excess skin as necessary to make each of the samples as physically similar to each other as possible, both to ensure even cooking times and assure the same influences on taste. (I am the first to admit that my butchering skills are, how to say this…inferior to any professional. I am sure there are many cooks out there who could have done a better job than me. But they weren’t in my kitchen two days ago, so too bad.) I then weighed the trimmed chicken on my digital kitchen scale. The net prices below were calculated by dividing the package price by the net weight of the trimmed and drained chicken leg. This price, of course, does not reflect the value of the leftover backs, which I will be making into stock…at some point in the near future. I swear I’m getting to it later today, right after I finish this crossword…
Finally it was cooking time. I slathered the legs with a generous amount of melted butter, and seasoned them with salt and pepper. Into the oven, out 45 minutes later. Then Andrew and I cut each of them up on separate plates randomly marked A through D for sampling. Andrew did not know which chicken was which, allowing him to evaluate them objectively. In the end this didn’t matter, since he and I ended up giving the legs identical ratings. Nathan’s assessment was less nuanced: “I want to eat the chicken one!” …Okay.
Here’s the rundown of the legs du jour and our highly scientific taste analysis, from least liked to our favourite:
Certified Organic chicken: Purchased at Whole Foods, these legs came from Beretta Organic Farms, a major supplier of organic meats in Southern Ontario. Beretta’s website advised me their chickens enjoy “unrestricted access to our farm landscape” and that I would “appreciate the difference in the meat compared to the bland grocery store poultry.” Huh. Two legs (with backs attached) were vacuum-packed in a slim plastic bag that was swanky black on one side. After draining the minimal amount of juice, I trimmed off the backs, a chore that was easier with these legs than it was with the discount chicken (next), since “backs” here only refers to the spine and not half a freakin’ carcass still attached. Yuck factor*: 2 out of 10. Cost in package: $10.98/kg. Net cost after draining and trimming: $13.81/kg.Disclosure: I worked at Whole Foods Yorkville for about four months after I finished culinary school in 2002. Despite their best efforts, I did not adopt their natural foods ethos.
I really expected this chicken to—at least—taste great. This bird had lived as a chicken should: out in the pasture, pecking for insects, roosting wherever it liked. Instead, it was the driest, blandest-tasting sample of our set. (Also: I didn’t notice an appreciable difference in my visage after sampling four whole bites of this stuff; yet another acne cure down the drain.) After the initial taste tests were complete it sat, limp and ignored, on the table while we chose tastier cuts with which to finish our meal.
Bag o’ chicken: A bag of chicken legs, available from discount grocers, in this case Food Basics. Loose-packed whole legs with the back attached—plus some excess skin for good measure—it invariably features a few stray bits of organ meat plus some pinkish liquid both inside the bag and out, giving it a yuck factor of 9. One might also assume that this chicken has received antibiotics and animal by-products at some point in its life, lived in crowded conditions, and may never have seen the sun. Cost in package: $3.99/kg. Net cost after draining and trimming: $5.90/kg.
Not surprisingly, this sample was also rather tasteless, although at least it wasn’t as dry as the organic chicken. It required the most up-front work too: bits of organ meat had to be cleaned off, and quite a bit of back carcass had to be removed. Once all that was accomplished, it was barely cheaper than the free-range option.
Regular ole chicken: The President’s Choice standard offering, a Styrofoam tray with an absorbent liner. The label boasted that the chicken was air-chilled (but said little else), leaving one to speculate whether it, too, was a sunless cannibal. These guys were nicely trimmed and arranged, and the outside of the package wasn’t slimy; yuck factor: 4. Cost in package: $8.65/kg. Net cost after draining: $8.70/kg (and a tear shed for the environmental atrocity that is its packaging).
Unlike the previous two samples, this one had a good, strong flavour that actually told us we were eating chicken. (Does your chicken speak to you, too? Good, I’m glad it’s not just me.) The meat was moist, and the taste almost equaled that of our winner. It would definitely be a good choice when the champion isn’t available.
Keeping it real chicken: This leg also hails from Whole Foods Oakville—in this case from the fresh meat counter, where it was wrapped in butcher’s paper (yay!). Both the friendly meat counter dude and the paper wrapper assured me that the chicken had enjoyed a great life, trouncing through daisies and dining on vegan fois gras. Okay maybe those were not the exact words, but the bird was raised free-range, without antibiotics, and consumed only a vegetarian diet (uh, I guess insects count as vegetarian). The butcher’s paper also pointed out that it received no added hormones, which it then footnoted that hormones were prohibited by federal regulations. So, gain one point for no hormones, lose one point for this not being an exceptional thing to boast of, and gain half a point for owning up to this fact, all in less words than I have used in this sentence. Too bad there’s no points in this game. Probably because this leg was sold over-the-counter, it was the only one that did not have any juices to drain. Yuck factor: 0. Cost in package: $6.90/kg. Net cost: same.
Whole Foods’ over-the-counter offering won Andrew’s and my taste-test hands-down (wings-down?). It was moist and flavourful. While the air-chilled chicken came very close, this sample had a depth of flavour not quite achieved by the PC offering. The clincher was that—in some way that we couldn’t quite define—its particular taste best represented quintessential “chickeness.”
So, what does all this add up to? I guess I’m gonna stop buying bags o’ chicken….
Seriously, these results were a total surprise. How is it that this free-range chicken tasted so awesome but the organic one did not? And why did the regular chicken—which I assume was raised quite differently—come in such a close second? To top it all off, finding the free-range chicken was nearly as cheap as discount-store chicken was quite a shocker (too bad I live 15 km away from Whole Foods…although I think I will be making the trip a little more often now). At the very least, we now know that we don’t have to shell out big bucks to enjoy premium chicken.
* Yuck factor is determined through a complicated algorithm** taking into account variables such as overall looks, packaging, gross liquids, featheriness, and how sticky my hands get just trying to put the damn package in a grocery cart.
** I don’t really, factually know what an algorithm is (it’s been a long time since high school calculus). But it makes the scale sound way more scientific than admitting it’s just subjective guessing, so that’s what I’m calling it.
Seeing as the antibiotic-free, free-roaming chicken was our clear winner, Andrew and I have resolved to compare a few different stores’ similar offerings at a future date. I’ll let you know how that goes.



No comments:
Post a Comment