Sunday, December 19, 2010

Not My Good Butter!

I can call up many anecdotes when it comes to butter. Cutting butter into flour to create my first pastry. Churning butter the hard way on a school field trip. Several classmates chanting “Fat equals flavour!” in college. But my favourite butter-related moment is when Marge Simpson gasps in horror at Homer using her good butter as a pencil holder (“Another tasty memo...”). Once while watching that episode on reruns, Andrew had turned to me and raised an eyebrow; I assured him that yes, there really was such a thing as good butter. Because, I was sure there was. That was the butter I bought for special occasions, such as Christmas, and never—ever—any other time of the year. Because, you know, five and a half bucks is pretty extravagant for butter.

But had I ever really put that premium butter to the test? (Hint: no.) Was it really worth including on my Things I Must Have Otherwise Christmas Will Be Ruined list? (I’ll admit it: I have ruined a couple holidays by failing to supply Superior Butter, but no one was the wiser, mostly because they had already been ruined by such infractions as Wrong Kind of Cheap Wine, Inadequate Decorations, and Improper Specialty Serve-Ware.) Time to face the truth.

I compared three salted butters: my usual cheapie from Neilson at $3.59, Lactantia’s Country Churned at $5.69, and Gay Lea at $5.59, all from Fortinos. All purchased at the same time, same one-pound blocks, stored together in the fridge to ensure temperature consistency. Each was tested by Andrew and myself, both straight up and slathered on rather tasteless sliced bread (bread will have its day in a future post; stay tuned). Like the chicken test, this was a blind comparison for Andrew but not myself. (Nathan taste-tested the butters too, but you don’t want to go there. Just…no.)

The first thing we noticed was that one of the three butters (Lactantia) was a noticeably darker yellow than the other two. Since none of them had colour added, we figured this would indicate a different taste or at least mouthfeel...it did not. In short: there’s no difference between the three. At all. Really. None. Same consistency, same texture, same taste.

I was totally amazed that my long-held belief in the existence of good butter was defeated by one taste-test. There goes that sacred cow…I guess I will have to come up with a more inspired way to ruin Christmas this year.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

The Spaghetti Files, parte due

This is the second installment in The Spaghetti Files. Read about my other spaghetti adventures here.

My second pasta trial featured Delverde spaghetti No. 4. In truth it was both my first and third trials, as I accidentally bought spaghettini (No. 3) instead of spaghetti the first time around, so I ended up cooking this brand twice (more on that below).
Delverde vs. Italpasta

Right off the bat, I have to say: Delverde has got some serious sensory appeal. It is lighter in colour than most other dried pastas (I tried to capture the difference compared to my regular Italpasta in the photo here), and its strands feel, dare I say, silky. I may or may not have rubbed this pasta on my cheek. This pasta somehow felt luxurious to me. In turn, I didn’t mind so much the $1.99 per pound price tag…it just seemed worth it. Let’s see if it could live up to my initial impression.

When it came time to cook, I felt almost sad throwing the noodles into a vat of boiling water; they were just so soft and pretty. Yes, this dried pasta made me emotional, in a way that heartless acts such as boiling live lobsters never has. I wonder if that means something about my psyche…nah.

After combining it with some spaghetti sauce, Andrew and I set ourselves to the careful process of assessing the pasta’s taste, texture, and chew. Nathan set himself to the less than careful process of inhaling the spaghetti as fast as possible while still managing to talk about Spider-man nonstop. (He later reported the new pasta tasted “good”—the exact same review he gives any food he is willing to taste more than once…a very broad category.) I wanted a bit more detail, so Andrew expanded that the pasta tasted fresher and—for lack of a better description—cleaner. I agreed—this pasta was a bit less sweet than our standard fare, and also seriously less gummy and sticky. At the end of the meal, Andrew reported feeling more satisfied than normal…the overall experience did not leave him wanting (me neither). The pasta continued to perform well as leftovers, too: it retained its fresh flavour and smooth texture (both when stored separately and already combined with sauce).

As mentioned above, my first batch of Delverde pasta was spaghettini. I couldn’t help but wonder if these improvements were really just the difference between spaghetti and spaghettini, instead of the brands. So we did the whole thing over again with spaghetti a couple weeks later. Overall, the results stood: the pasta still tasted fresher and more refined than our typical brand, and the leftovers did not succumb to gumminess. The spaghettini was a bit superior to the spaghetti, however; it just tasted a little bit better, felt a little bit smoother than the spaghetti (a few minutes shaved off the cooking time during a busy weeknight didn’t hurt, either).

Overall, I am impressed by Delverde pasta. It was great to feel satisfied at the end of a plate of “the same old spaghetti,” instead of picking at extras, trying to find that last bite that will taste as good as I imagine it should. I think I am going to miss it as I proceed to test other brands over the next couple months…maybe I will sneak in a third date in between. 

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

The Spaghetti Files, parte una

I make some pretty good pasta sauces. Sometimes it’s my own take on one of the classics from my childhood, sometimes it’s a restaurant rip-off, and sometimes I just follow an already perfect recipe. What I don’t make is great pasta. For years I have relied on Italpasta’s standard two pound bags of noodles, because it is good enough and not too expensive (I have tried no name pasta once or twice…I learn from my mistakes). But the fact is, pasta at home does not taste as good as pasta at a restaurant. And I really think some of my sauces deserve better…especially if it means I will yearn for 1000-calorie plates of restaurant pasta a little less often.

Contestant number one was precious: Artigiano Pastaio Cav. Giuseppe Cocco Spaghetti no. 33 (??), direct from Fara San Martino, Italy (imported by Italpasta, go figure). At $3.99 for 500 grams, it was the most expensive of the dry semolina pastas at Fortinos. But, I reasoned, I get about six to eight servings to a pound, so it’s really only 50 cents a serving. Not horrible, especially compared to $17 a plate at il ristorante.

The flat noodles also offered by this brand have an almost flaky appearance, making them appear hand-rolled, and perhaps dried in the sun. The packaging adds to the feeling that this stuff is special: nearly all of the sales pitch is in Italian, so much so that it took me a while to figure out what the actual company name was. This stuff is too good for them to bother getting it translated: it sells itself! My computer’s free translator widget helpfully translated it thus:

To Fara San Martino to make the Pasta it is an ancient tradition for the favourable climate, the pure water and the good air. This pasta is not that modern, because it is made scrupulously with the ancient prescription of Fara San Martino, using the better semolina and the water than source, (eggs fresh for the Pasta to the egg), it draws rough of bronze, with asciugamento to lowland temperature and producing of little. Truly as it was made once, in handicraft way.

Feeling less than enlightened by such a description, I sought out the actual company website, which clarified that the pasta was “manufactured by mixing durum wheat semolina and cold spring water. Slow cold mixing, round bronze-die cutting; slow and static low-temperature drying.” Nifty.

Time to cook! I did my usual: dutch oven fulla water, some salt, a bit of olive oil. Cooked according to the package directions, plus an extra minute or so because that’s the way we like it. The first thing I noticed while cooking was this pasta released so much starch that the cooking water looked like milk. It was so opaque I couldn’t see the noodles under the surface by the time it was done. Was this good or bad? I kept an open mind.

That open mind snapped shut when I took my first bite. With that bite, I instantly was transported to…calculating how much money I could have saved by buying cheaper, better pasta. Ugh. A complete lack of flavour combined with a soft, gluey chew left me wondering if it was too late to cook up a batch of anything else. Maybe that milk-water was a warning: Beware! Everything you enjoy in your pasta has leached out here! Both Andrew and I quickly found ourselves seeking out something good to eat to wash away the memory of dutifully finishing our dinner. Thank goodness for foccacia.

On the bright side, my spaghetti experiments can only go up from here…I hope.

Friday, October 8, 2010

Tastes Like Chicken

I have been wondering about chicken for a while now (haven’t you?). No, no, not the which-came-first thing (it was the egg, don’t get me started). I’ve been wondering if there’s actually a difference between the various chicken offerings—organic, free-range, grain-fed, antibiotic free—in the market. What I mean is, yes, obviously one difference is that some of these chickens are controlling themselves and refraining from eating ground up bits of their brethren, and eschewing drugs, and maybe even exercising a bit. But what really keeps me up at night (um, not really) is this: Do they taste different? Do they cook up differently? Is any of this going to make dinner better and leftovers more palatable? Really: are these birds worth the extra cash?

When it comes to the lowly chicken, the price range can be vast. Last week I found chicken prices ranging from $3.99 to $10.98 a kilo. That’s an almost 300% difference. The first price was from a discount grocer and the second from an upscale market. They are both from the same day, for the same cut (whole leg, bone-in, backs attached), both the same expiry date. The only variable? One is organic.

Even if I were to take organic out of the equation, there is still a huge price difference between various poultry choices. I could opt for aforementioned discount legs—conveniently tossed loose in a bag—or the more attractively packaged (but worse for the earth?) Styrofoam tray of legs for $8.65 a kilo. (This direct comparison begins to run into some difficulty here as the cuts are a bit different; more on that below.) Or maybe I should hedge my bets and buy the “free of everything nasty except still not eating organic because he thinks that’s taking things just one step too far” chicken for $6.90 a kilo. (Wait! Did I just say it was cheaper than conventional—cannibal—chicken? Yes, yes I did.)

So, there was only one thing to do…some unregulated testing on my loved ones. I decided to go whole-hog, er, whole chicken…leg…and compare several options. I chose legs over breasts because—with a stronger flavour to begin with—I figured any variance in taste would be more noticeable. After bouncing between three different grocers to obtain a total of four samples in a single day, I butchered them as necessary and tossed them in my fridge for a day to ensure they were the same temperature. Finally I roasted them together, after which they were carefully assessed by my crack team of me, my husband, and our six-year-old. (We’re “experts” now. I’m slapping that on my résumé, baby.)

A note on trimming: Two of the four samples (the cheapest and most expensive, go figure) came with the backs attached. I trimmed away the backs and excess skin as necessary to make each of the samples as physically similar to each other as possible, both to ensure even cooking times and assure the same influences on taste. (I am the first to admit that my butchering skills are, how to say this…inferior to any professional. I am sure there are many cooks out there who could have done a better job than me. But they weren’t in my kitchen two days ago, so too bad.) I then weighed the trimmed chicken on my digital kitchen scale. The net prices below were calculated by dividing the package price by the net weight of the trimmed and drained chicken leg. This price, of course, does not reflect the value of the leftover backs, which I will be making into stock…at some point in the near future. I swear I’m getting to it later today, right after I finish this crossword…

Finally it was cooking time. I slathered the legs with a generous amount of melted butter, and seasoned them with salt and pepper. Into the oven, out 45 minutes later. Then Andrew and I cut each of them up on separate plates randomly marked A through D for sampling. Andrew did not know which chicken was which, allowing him to evaluate them objectively. In the end this didn’t matter, since he and I ended up giving the legs identical ratings. Nathan’s assessment was less nuanced: “I want to eat the chicken one!” …Okay.

Here’s the rundown of the legs du jour and our highly scientific taste analysis, from least liked to our favourite:

Certified Organic chicken: Purchased at Whole Foods, these legs came from Beretta Organic Farms, a major supplier of organic meats in Southern Ontario. Beretta’s website advised me their chickens enjoy “unrestricted access to our farm landscape” and that I would “appreciate the difference in the meat compared to the bland grocery store poultry.” Huh. Two legs (with backs attached) were vacuum-packed in a slim plastic bag that was swanky black on one side. After draining the minimal amount of juice, I trimmed off the backs, a chore that was easier with these legs than it was with the discount chicken (next), since “backs” here only refers to the spine and not half a freakin’ carcass still attached. Yuck factor*: 2 out of 10. Cost in package: $10.98/kg. Net cost after draining and trimming: $13.81/kg.

Disclosure: I worked at Whole Foods Yorkville for about four months after I finished culinary school in 2002. Despite their best efforts, I did not adopt their natural foods ethos.

I really expected this chicken to—at least—taste great. This bird had lived as a chicken should: out in the pasture, pecking for insects, roosting wherever it liked. Instead, it was the driest, blandest-tasting sample of our set. (Also: I didn’t notice an appreciable difference in my visage after sampling four whole bites of this stuff; yet another acne cure down the drain.) After the initial taste tests were complete it sat, limp and ignored, on the table while we chose tastier cuts with which to finish our meal.

Bag o’ chicken: A bag of chicken legs, available from discount grocers, in this case Food Basics. Loose-packed whole legs with the back attached—plus some excess skin for good measure—it invariably features a few stray bits of organ meat plus some pinkish liquid both inside the bag and out, giving it a yuck factor of 9. One might also assume that this chicken has received antibiotics and animal by-products at some point in its life, lived in crowded conditions, and may never have seen the sun. Cost in package: $3.99/kg. Net cost after draining and trimming: $5.90/kg.

Not surprisingly, this sample was also rather tasteless, although at least it wasn’t as dry as the organic chicken. It required the most up-front work too: bits of organ meat had to be cleaned off, and quite a bit of back carcass had to be removed. Once all that was accomplished, it was barely cheaper than the free-range option.

Regular ole chicken: The President’s Choice standard offering, a Styrofoam tray with an absorbent liner. The label boasted that the chicken was air-chilled (but said little else), leaving one to speculate whether it, too, was a sunless cannibal. These guys were nicely trimmed and arranged, and the outside of the package wasn’t slimy; yuck factor: 4. Cost in package: $8.65/kg. Net cost after draining: $8.70/kg (and a tear shed for the environmental atrocity that is its packaging).

Unlike the previous two samples, this one had a good, strong flavour that actually told us we were eating chicken. (Does your chicken speak to you, too? Good, I’m glad it’s not just me.) The meat was moist, and the taste almost equaled that of our winner. It would definitely be a good choice when the champion isn’t available.

Keeping it real chicken: This leg also hails from Whole Foods Oakville—in this case from the fresh meat counter, where it was wrapped in butcher’s paper (yay!). Both the friendly meat counter dude and the paper wrapper assured me that the chicken had enjoyed a great life, trouncing through daisies and dining on vegan fois gras. Okay maybe those were not the exact words, but the bird was raised free-range, without antibiotics, and consumed only a vegetarian diet (uh, I guess insects count as vegetarian). The butcher’s paper also pointed out that it received no added hormones, which it then footnoted that hormones were prohibited by federal regulations. So, gain one point for no hormones, lose one point for this not being an exceptional thing to boast of, and gain half a point for owning up to this fact, all in less words than I have used in this sentence. Too bad there’s no points in this game. Probably because this leg was sold over-the-counter, it was the only one that did not have any juices to drain. Yuck factor: 0. Cost in package: $6.90/kg. Net cost: same.

Whole Foods’ over-the-counter offering won Andrew’s and my taste-test hands-down (wings-down?). It was moist and flavourful. While the air-chilled chicken came very close, this sample had a depth of flavour not quite achieved by the PC offering. The clincher was that—in some way that we couldn’t quite define—its particular taste best represented quintessential “chickeness.”

So, what does all this add up to? I guess I’m gonna stop buying bags o’ chicken….


Seriously, these results were a total surprise. How is it that this free-range chicken tasted so awesome but the organic one did not? And why did the regular chicken—which I assume was raised quite differently—come in such a close second? To top it all off, finding the free-range chicken was nearly as cheap as discount-store chicken was quite a shocker (too bad I live 15 km away from Whole Foods…although I think I will be making the trip a little more often now). At the very least, we now know that we don’t have to shell out big bucks to enjoy premium chicken.

* Yuck factor is determined through a complicated algorithm** taking into account variables such as overall looks, packaging, gross liquids, featheriness, and how sticky my hands get just trying to put the damn package in a grocery cart.

** I don’t really, factually know what an algorithm is (it’s been a long time since high school calculus). But it makes the scale sound way more scientific than admitting it’s just subjective guessing, so that’s what I’m calling it.

Seeing as the antibiotic-free, free-roaming chicken was our clear winner, Andrew and I have resolved to compare a few different stores’ similar offerings at a future date. I’ll let you know how that goes.

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

For Want of Four Dollars

A couple weeks ago our friends Lisa and Simon came over for a family play date (the kids play with toys and the adults play with the liquor cabinet. Fun for everyone!). Once the kids were entrenched in the toy bonanza that is our basement, Lisa and I made a trip out to Denninger’s, an upscale Euro-import grocer, to assemble a collection of disgustingly fattening foods for dinner. On our previous (and my first) trip, we had made a pact to try a selection of whatever foods grabbed our attention. So there we were, loading up on sausage rolls, apple strudel (“It’s hand-made by someone named Helga! It has to be good!”), a mystery food intriguingly named poutine balls*, and…frozen pierogi.

The first time I ever had pierogi was from a Polish association’s pavilion at a multicultural festival in Edmonton. They were the epitome of a classic pierogi: potato-stuffed, topped with sour cream, bacon bits, and spring onions. I sat on the lawn with my family, watching a troupe of Japanese drummers and dancers go crazy on a gong, and proceeded to stuff my face. They were so delicious; I wondered aloud how I had lived for 12 whole years without these lovelies gracing my palate (all right, maybe I wasn’t quite so eloquent…but my recollections are). My parents gave me a nod and pat on the head: “Enjoy them now kid, because you won’t be seeing them again for a while.” **

I wouldn’t have the chance to eat pierogi again until my early 20s, when I bought a frozen package from my friendly local national-chain grocer. Those frozen, er, nuggets were, in a word, awful. They were pasty and tasteless; they had an unappetizing texture and even less appealing aftertaste. They didn’t cook up so much as shift their temperature. They were so bad they made me doubt my childhood memory: maybe I imagined that these things tasted good? Were all pierogi actually like this? Was twelve-year-old self unable to distinguish between wall putty and actual food? Was it all the effect of being a tourist at a special event on a warm summer day? Did I even actually eat pierogi that mythical day?

Anyway, after trying the couple different brands available at my regular large-chain grocer, I gave up in disgust. Andrew assured me that it wasn’t my imagination, pierogi could taste good…but only if made by an honest-to-goodness Polish or Ukrainian grandmother (a privilege he had enjoyed at friends’ houses during his Torontonian youth). This information only further disheartened me: there aren’t exactly many Polish takeouts in the ’burbs. But—after all the disappointments and heartaches (what can I say, I get emotional about these things), I still held a torch for pierogi. Someday—someday—I would find my pierogi soul mate….

Back to Denninger’s where, sitting in the freezer display in front of us, were more pierogi than I’ve ever seen in a single grocery store…and this is a store that actually has a reputation at stake. We decided to take the plunge. They were expensive, but it had probably been about ten years since my last attempt to cook these things, so I was willing to bite the bullet. I wanted to believe my years of pining had not been for naught.

We came home, cooked up everything, and sat down to our debauchery.

We had bought two different packages of pierogi: one stuffed with spinach and feta (a combo I can now say with authority is better suited to encasement in phyllo dough), the other featuring a classic potato and cheddar filling. I took one bite of the potato/cheddar pierogi and could taste the difference right away: these were the dumplings I had remembered. I felt vindicated! It was not all in my imagination; I was not some crazy, false-memory generating whack-job who would always pine for the good old days where everything tasted like heaven. (Is it reaching to confirm my sanity through a frozen dinner? Oh well; it’s the best option I have.) My problem was not that pierogi—at best—universally tasted like boredom, no, no. My true problem is: I have been buying crappy food.

Which brings me to my point: after my initial, blissful contact had been made, it took me 24 years to taste a good pierogi again. Because I was buying crappy food...possibly at a crappy grocery store. Specifically: cheap crappy food. It had somehow never occurred to me that I should just try going a bit out of my way to a specialty store, spend a few extra bucks; that a little bit of extra money and effort was all that was separating something so awful it threw my whole worldview into disarray (yes, I am being melodramatic…is it obvious?) from something that I might actually enjoy.

(And what was the actual difference, you might ask? $3.99 and a five minute drive. That’s how much a ¾ pound bag of frozen pierogi cost at Denninger’s. I had lost out on 24 years of pierogi heaven for want of four dollars.)

Apparently, they weren’t even that good: Andrew has since informed me they wouldn’t have held a candle to the real deal, à la Polish immigrant grandmothers. So, now I am wondering: how good can it get? Denninger’s had some pricier pierogi available that day; would they be even better? Enough to impress someone spoiled on authentic old-world fare? Most importantly, would they be worth the (gasp) extra cost?

If a couple dollars’ difference between pierogi results in polar opposite meals, could the same be said of other foods? What about pastas, breads, cereals, snacks, sauces, cheese, and—the truly big-ticket item—meat? Do premium foods (and premium grocers) have something to offer that I have been missing out on?

I think it’s time I found out.

* A sphere of gravy ensconced in a tater tot. We still aren’t sure if they were right by nature or not.
** This memory is a dramatization. Do not attempt.

So what am I actually doing? For the next few months (or however long my bank account holds out), I will be deliberately seeking out upscale, specialty, and higher-priced alternatives to my normal fare, cooking them up as I would normally, and reporting on the results here. This is a completely biased, unscientific project: most of the time my family is aware that an ingredient has been switched out, and there will be few side-by-side, direct comparisons. Mostly we will just be eating dinner like normal, and try to assess if a particular food substitution makes it taste better, and/or makes us more beautiful/smarter/popular people. Because food has that power, you know.