But had I ever really put that premium butter to the test? (Hint: no.) Was it really worth including on my Things I Must Have Otherwise Christmas Will Be Ruined list? (I’ll admit it: I have ruined a couple holidays by failing to supply Superior Butter, but no one was the wiser, mostly because they had already been ruined by such infractions as Wrong Kind of Cheap Wine, Inadequate Decorations, and Improper Specialty Serve-Ware.) Time to face the truth.
I compared three salted butters: my usual cheapie from Neilson at $3.59, Lactantia’s Country Churned at $5.69, and Gay Lea at $5.59, all from Fortinos. All purchased at the same time, same one-pound blocks, stored together in the fridge to ensure temperature consistency. Each was tested by Andrew and myself, both straight up and slathered on rather tasteless sliced bread (bread will have its day in a future post; stay tuned). Like the chicken test, this was a blind comparison for Andrew but not myself. (Nathan taste-tested the butters too, but you don’t want to go there. Just…no.)
The first thing we noticed was that one of the three butters (Lactantia) was a noticeably darker yellow than the other two. Since none of them had colour added, we figured this would indicate a different taste or at least mouthfeel...it did not. In short: there’s no difference between the three. At all. Really. None. Same consistency, same texture, same taste.
I was totally amazed that my long-held belief in the existence of good butter was defeated by one taste-test. There goes that sacred cow…I guess I will have to come up with a more inspired way to ruin Christmas this year.