Tuesday, September 21, 2010

For Want of Four Dollars

A couple weeks ago our friends Lisa and Simon came over for a family play date (the kids play with toys and the adults play with the liquor cabinet. Fun for everyone!). Once the kids were entrenched in the toy bonanza that is our basement, Lisa and I made a trip out to Denninger’s, an upscale Euro-import grocer, to assemble a collection of disgustingly fattening foods for dinner. On our previous (and my first) trip, we had made a pact to try a selection of whatever foods grabbed our attention. So there we were, loading up on sausage rolls, apple strudel (“It’s hand-made by someone named Helga! It has to be good!”), a mystery food intriguingly named poutine balls*, and…frozen pierogi.

The first time I ever had pierogi was from a Polish association’s pavilion at a multicultural festival in Edmonton. They were the epitome of a classic pierogi: potato-stuffed, topped with sour cream, bacon bits, and spring onions. I sat on the lawn with my family, watching a troupe of Japanese drummers and dancers go crazy on a gong, and proceeded to stuff my face. They were so delicious; I wondered aloud how I had lived for 12 whole years without these lovelies gracing my palate (all right, maybe I wasn’t quite so eloquent…but my recollections are). My parents gave me a nod and pat on the head: “Enjoy them now kid, because you won’t be seeing them again for a while.” **

I wouldn’t have the chance to eat pierogi again until my early 20s, when I bought a frozen package from my friendly local national-chain grocer. Those frozen, er, nuggets were, in a word, awful. They were pasty and tasteless; they had an unappetizing texture and even less appealing aftertaste. They didn’t cook up so much as shift their temperature. They were so bad they made me doubt my childhood memory: maybe I imagined that these things tasted good? Were all pierogi actually like this? Was twelve-year-old self unable to distinguish between wall putty and actual food? Was it all the effect of being a tourist at a special event on a warm summer day? Did I even actually eat pierogi that mythical day?

Anyway, after trying the couple different brands available at my regular large-chain grocer, I gave up in disgust. Andrew assured me that it wasn’t my imagination, pierogi could taste good…but only if made by an honest-to-goodness Polish or Ukrainian grandmother (a privilege he had enjoyed at friends’ houses during his Torontonian youth). This information only further disheartened me: there aren’t exactly many Polish takeouts in the ’burbs. But—after all the disappointments and heartaches (what can I say, I get emotional about these things), I still held a torch for pierogi. Someday—someday—I would find my pierogi soul mate….

Back to Denninger’s where, sitting in the freezer display in front of us, were more pierogi than I’ve ever seen in a single grocery store…and this is a store that actually has a reputation at stake. We decided to take the plunge. They were expensive, but it had probably been about ten years since my last attempt to cook these things, so I was willing to bite the bullet. I wanted to believe my years of pining had not been for naught.

We came home, cooked up everything, and sat down to our debauchery.

We had bought two different packages of pierogi: one stuffed with spinach and feta (a combo I can now say with authority is better suited to encasement in phyllo dough), the other featuring a classic potato and cheddar filling. I took one bite of the potato/cheddar pierogi and could taste the difference right away: these were the dumplings I had remembered. I felt vindicated! It was not all in my imagination; I was not some crazy, false-memory generating whack-job who would always pine for the good old days where everything tasted like heaven. (Is it reaching to confirm my sanity through a frozen dinner? Oh well; it’s the best option I have.) My problem was not that pierogi—at best—universally tasted like boredom, no, no. My true problem is: I have been buying crappy food.

Which brings me to my point: after my initial, blissful contact had been made, it took me 24 years to taste a good pierogi again. Because I was buying crappy food...possibly at a crappy grocery store. Specifically: cheap crappy food. It had somehow never occurred to me that I should just try going a bit out of my way to a specialty store, spend a few extra bucks; that a little bit of extra money and effort was all that was separating something so awful it threw my whole worldview into disarray (yes, I am being melodramatic…is it obvious?) from something that I might actually enjoy.

(And what was the actual difference, you might ask? $3.99 and a five minute drive. That’s how much a ¾ pound bag of frozen pierogi cost at Denninger’s. I had lost out on 24 years of pierogi heaven for want of four dollars.)

Apparently, they weren’t even that good: Andrew has since informed me they wouldn’t have held a candle to the real deal, à la Polish immigrant grandmothers. So, now I am wondering: how good can it get? Denninger’s had some pricier pierogi available that day; would they be even better? Enough to impress someone spoiled on authentic old-world fare? Most importantly, would they be worth the (gasp) extra cost?

If a couple dollars’ difference between pierogi results in polar opposite meals, could the same be said of other foods? What about pastas, breads, cereals, snacks, sauces, cheese, and—the truly big-ticket item—meat? Do premium foods (and premium grocers) have something to offer that I have been missing out on?

I think it’s time I found out.

* A sphere of gravy ensconced in a tater tot. We still aren’t sure if they were right by nature or not.
** This memory is a dramatization. Do not attempt.

So what am I actually doing? For the next few months (or however long my bank account holds out), I will be deliberately seeking out upscale, specialty, and higher-priced alternatives to my normal fare, cooking them up as I would normally, and reporting on the results here. This is a completely biased, unscientific project: most of the time my family is aware that an ingredient has been switched out, and there will be few side-by-side, direct comparisons. Mostly we will just be eating dinner like normal, and try to assess if a particular food substitution makes it taste better, and/or makes us more beautiful/smarter/popular people. Because food has that power, you know.